Residents of Kfar Aza gathered on Wednesday to mark the third anniversary of the October 7, 2023 attacks that killed 64 of their neighbors and took 19 hostage. The ceremony began just after 07:00 local time, the moment gunmen killed half of the kibbutz’s 14‑member civil defence squad.
Inbar Goldstein, whose brother and niece died and four relatives were taken captive, said she wants her country to accept responsibility for the failures that allowed the assault. "I need my country to take responsibility," she said.
The attacks resulted in roughly 1,200 deaths across southern Israel and the abduction of about 251 people. No independent investigation has examined how the security lapse unfolded, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who was in office at the time, is again seeking re‑election on a platform of strength against Israel’s enemies.
Prior to the assault, several young female soldiers stationed near the Gaza border had warned their superiors about possible preparations by Hamas. One of them, Roni Eshel, was among 15 soldiers killed when gunmen overran their base at Nahal Oz, adjacent to Kfar Aza. Her uncle, Elad Levy, asked whether warnings from Egypt, the United Arab Emirates or other sources were ignored by Netanyahu.
Reuters reported that, in the weeks before October 7, security officials had relayed concerns to Netanyahu, which his office has denied. A recent book excerpt cited a call from the UAE president to Netanyahu ten days earlier, warning of a major Hamas operation; Netanyahu’s office called the claim "an absolute lie" and said it would pursue legal action.
Netanyahu has placed blame on security chiefs, asserting they chose not to wake him before the attacks to avoid ordering a full‑scale military response. He told right‑wing Channel 14 that doing so would have prevented the assault.
The former IDF spokesperson, Col. Richard Hecht, said the political leadership’s refusal to accept responsibility contributed to his resignation six months after the attacks. At a memorial in Jerusalem, a father of a victim confronted Netanyahu, accusing him of failing to protect his son and demanding accountability.
Calls for a state‑mandated commission of inquiry have intensified. Former minister Yizhar Shai, whose son was killed on October 7, argues that the upcoming election is being held "almost blindfolded" without a thorough, sworn explanation from the prime minister. Netanyahu has rejected a Supreme Court‑led inquiry, proposing instead a politically appointed commission that was never passed before parliament adjourned.
Opposition figures such as Gadi Eisenkot have supported the demand for an independent investigation. A satirical video game released by Eisenkot’s team, titled "Sleepy Bibi," lets players evade warnings of an attack, reflecting public frustration with Netanyahu’s stance.
Analysts note that the legacy of October 7 presents a dual narrative: one of security failures that led to the Hamas incursion, and another that portrays Netanyahu as having reshaped the region and restored Israeli strength. Polls suggest the attacks remain a pivotal issue for voters as the election approaches.
The shadow of the attacks continues to divide Israeli society, with supporters viewing Netanyahu as essential for security and critics warning that his political survival could jeopardize accountability.

